In the mainstream perception of blended Scotch, there’s Johnnie Walker, and then there’s everything else. The Diageo-owned giant can feel omnipresent in both liquor stores and bars, with visibility boosted by recent special editions and entertainment crossovers. (The “White Walker” “Game of Thrones” collab seemed too fitting to not exist.)
And while the whisky world has grown both wider and deeper in recent decades, Johnnie Walker remains the best-selling Scotch, with roughly 22.1 million cases shipped in 2023. For reference, that’s more than 2.5 times the volume of Ballantine’s, its nearest competitor. It’s tough to imagine Johnnie’s market dominance changing anytime soon. Diageo operates around 30 distilleries throughout Scotland, giving the brand access to an incredible variety of both single malt and single grain liquid streams. Like many blenders, it’s also believed the brand sources from and trades whiskies with producers outside its company portfolio.
The brand’s Red Label has long held the title as the world’s best-selling blended Scotch, and over the past ~115 years, Johnnie Walker’s core lineup has shifted, with a variety of expressions introduced and retired. Today, we’re examining, tasting, and ranking the brand’s current six core bottlings, in increasing order of flavor and quality.
Don’t Miss A Drop
Get the latest in beer, wine, and cocktail culture sent straight to your inbox.
6. Johnnie Walker Red Label
ABV: 40%
MSRP: ~$22.99
Type: Blended Scotch Whisky
The world’s best-selling blended Scotch, Johnnie Walker Red Label traces its origins back to 1909. Like most Johnnie blends, the exact proportions shift over time as the blending team attempts to maintain consistency with ever-changing stock. But the bigger and broader the blend, the more levers there are to pull, and Red Label pulls from up to 35 different whiskies per batch. (Diageo highlights Cardhu, Coal Ila, Cameronbridge, and Teaninich as some specific sources.)
Tasting Notes: The early scents are slightly grainy but build in complexity given enough time. It’s fruit-forward with both orchard and tropical fruits, and the first aromas hit like a balanced blend of apple, pineapple, and papaya, and orange juices. Small touches of oak and clove oil add some depth, along with restrained salinity and a touch of creosote. The fruit aromas evolve toward fire-grilled with more time in the glass. At first sip, it’s easy to see how Red Label maintains its status as a best seller and ever-popular mixer. The palate leans sweet with cream soda, vanilla frosting, butterscotch, smoked maple syrup, and diluted honey syrup. Light smoke (and again, smoked or charred fruit, particularly peach and pineapple) builds on the second sip and provides some nice depth on what might otherwise be a one-trick medley of sweetness. Those aforementioned flavors combine to baked ham with pineapple and clove. The finish is on the short side, but some of the clove spice and smoke linger for a not-insignificant amount of time.
Summary: There’s nothing offensive about Johnnie Walker Red Label, but in the scope of the brand’s core offerings, this one is more adaptable workhorse than highlight dram. Sipped neat, it feels like a spirit designed to be restrained and begging for a complement of something else. As the brand itself states, this is a whisky “perfect served with mixers or transformed into cocktails.” Enjoy accordingly.
5. Johnnie Walker Black Label
ABV: 40%
MSRP: ~$39.99 to $49.99
Type: Blended Scotch Whisky
Johnnie Walker Black Label is Red Label’s age-stated, slightly upstream sibling, another stalwart of the line dating back to the early 1900s. And it’s likely the world’s second-most- famous blended Scotch behind Red Label. Sourced from the “four corners of Scotland,” the youngest whisky in the bottle is 12 years old, and according to the brand, it’s meant to occupy a versatile middle ground in the lineup, enjoyable neat, on the rocks, or in a slightly more premium cocktail.
Tasting Notes: On the nose — which is at once oaky, spiced, and lightly astringent — Black Label immediately evokes what one might (correctly) come to expect in a blended Scotch. That is, nearly full-spectrum depth. Floral sweetness (rose water, lilac, and even lavender) pairs with seasoned oak before cinnamon, allspice, and white pepper waft upward. Canned pears in syrup add a touch of fruit, while damp embers and linseed oil bookend the nose. Peat, saltwater taffy, and sweetened grain porridge dominate the early palate, along with a hint of coconut flakes. Almond cookies and smoked malt lead a relatively short midpalate, with a mouthfeel some drinkers will wish had a touch more viscosity. The medium-length finish lends a tiny pops of campfire-roasted fruit (the fruitiest segment of the entire dram), smoke, and wood sugars.
Summary: It’s easy to want more out of Johnnie Walker Black. (Simple to say about a lot of whiskies.) That said, it’s ultimately an accessible, reliable sipper with enough flavor to leave an impact across each phase from nose to palate to finish. I always find myself wishing for more structure on the midpalate, but a solid finish ultimately helps make up for any shortfalls there.
4. Johnnie Walker Double Black
ABV: 40% ABV
MSRP: $44.99
Type: Blended Scotch Whisky
Introduced in 2011 and marketed as the “rebellious younger sibling of Johnnie Walker Black Label,” Johnnie Walker Double Black is a non-age-stated blended Scotch. (It’s easy to assume the overall blend is younger than Black Label, but that’s not necessarily fact across every bottling.) This particular expression is blended from unspecified whiskies from the west coast of Scotland, selected for “their naturally smoky flavour.” Labeled a Blended Scotch Whisky, Johnnie Walker Double Black is also marketed as a “double malt blend,” which signifies a blend of malt whiskies from at least two different distilleries.
Tasting Notes: As advertised, on the nose, Double Black comes out swinging as a punchier, richer version of Black Label. Though both are bottled at 80 proof, Double Black noses a touch higher, with many of its sibling’s notes dialed up. The nose is less floral and undeniably smokier, with burning leaves joining up with more subdued campfire embers. Spice is also amplified; whereas Black Label only eventually divulges scents of cinnamon and pepper, Double Black puts those front and center, along with a pleasing thread of preserved ginger. Double Black still carries that same linseed oil note, but it’s less noticeable amid bolder scents, resulting in a nose that’s less overtly chemical. The early palate brings more grilled orchard fruits alongside orange marmalade, dusted cocoa, and pink bubblegum. Those flavors are all ensconced within a surprisingly complex array of smoke, creosote, and charcoal. Porridge is present but reserved for the midpalate, which occupies significantly more space than the previous dram. The finish is mildly spiced, remarkably big on both almond and vanilla extracts.
Summary: Personally, I waffle back and forth between Black Label and Double Black. And while they’re noticeably different, in ranking the five core expressions, these two land closest together for me. But while Black Label may have the edge on balanced composition for mixing, Double Black’s more pronounced flavors make it the head-to-head winner for sipping neat. But I won’t hesitate to reach for it when mixing drinks for a smokier profile.
3. Johnnie Walker Gold Label Reserve
ABV: 40%
MSRP: $69.99
Type: Blended Scotch Whisky
Upon hitting the market in 2012, Johnnie Walker Gold Label Reserve became the successor to the previous Gold Label expression, which carried an 18-year age statement. This contemporary version is non-age-stated, made from malt and grain whiskies “chosen for their sweet, honeyed qualities.”
Tasting Notes: One of the more complex early noses in Johnnie Walker’s core range, Gold Label Reserve certainly delivers on its “sweet, honeyed” advertising with aromas of lavender-infused simple syrup, vanilla donut frosting, and — yes, as promised — warm honey. Herbal notes include rosemary, cardamom pods, and even fennel. But the real standout note for me on this tasting (not necessarily in intensity but in surprise) is a bold thread of mint, both spearmint and wintergreen. Bright red maraschino cherry adds even more fruit depth to the medley. The first sip falls right in line, a balance between those sweet notes in roughly equal proportion, followed by a can’t-shake-it combo of mint tea and sweet mint gum. The midpalate is carried by a thicker-than-usual mouthfeel for Johnnie Walker base expressions, which builds to light tropical fruit and barely-there smoke. The finish tastes like honeycomb grilled with rosemary, not terribly punchy in flavor but a suitable decrescendo from the varied palate.
Summary: The modern version of Gold Label Reserve is a mighty sweet dram with a minty twist that adds to the experience instead of overpowering. The presence of maraschino cherry and a composed, more viscous midpalate elevates the bottle above Johnnie Walker’s more basic and common offerings.
2. Johnnie Walker Green Label
ABV: 43%
MSRP: $64.99
Type: Blended Malt Scotch Whisky
First released in 1997, Johnnie Walker Green Label is unique among the brand’s core offerings in that it’s blended entirely from single malts, with no single grain whisky added. As such, it’s the only “Blended Malt Scotch Whisky” on this list. (And at 43 percent ABV, it’s the highest proof of all whiskies assessed here.) It carries a 15-year age statement, with whisky from sources including Talisker, Linkwood, Cragganmore, and Caol Ila.
Tasting Notes: Green Label’s nose starts earthy, and in a fun way; I’m almost instantly transported to an earthen warehouse, aromas of dirt, oak, and angel’s share surrounding my senses. The nose gets lighter, fruitier, and more floral with time, adjacent to potpourri without quite getting there. Golden pear, raisins, apricots, starfruit, and tart red plum cross with light peat and beeswax. Honeycomb and apricot lead the early palate. Cedar is a commonly cited tasting note on Green Label, though I personally find it a little closer to spruce pitch or other naturally derived versions of chewing gum. On the midpalate, there’s a quick turn toward very sweet and cereal notes, a bit like Frosted Wheaties with smoked maple syrup drizzled on top. The finish turns pleasantly astringent, with enough wood to remind us of the whisky’s age and pedigree — and enough peat to add character to the continued presence of sugary cereal that might otherwise turn cloying.
Summary: During tasting, there were several points when I thought Green Label might engineer a surprise upset. It’s undeniably one of the tastiest expressions in Johnnie Walker’s core lineup, and by many measures it’s the best value in the entire run. The slightly higher ABV also gives it a likely leg up on its cousins and siblings here. Green Label exists at a rare intersection of age, flavor, and value. And that’s a very good thing, because I’ll be looking for a restock soon enough.
1. Johnnie Walker Blue Label
ABV: 40% ABV
MSPR: ~$170-$250
Type: Blended Malt Scotch Whisky
Since its introduction in 1992, Johnnie Walker Blue has stood atop the world of premium blended Scotch as a highly recognizable bottle, often associated with high-end gifting and special occasions. It was first labeled as “Johnnie Walker Oldest” before a mid-’90s rebrand, though to be clear, it remains a non-age-stated blend. Blue Label is also associated with numerous special-edition releases, but today, we’re looking at the standard blend.
Tasting Notes: While bottled at 40 percent ABV, Johnnie Walker Blue Label has always nosed above that to me, closer to something in the 42–43 percent range. And throughout the years, with ever shifting stocks, the whisky has stayed consistent in reminding me of a spring day: a diverse bouquet of blooming flowers, where pollen-laden blossoms meet diluted honey syrup and spicy pink peppercorns. Red candy apples, almond extract, toasted oak, and sawgrass round out the aromas on the top end expression among Johnnie’s core offerings. At first taste, Blue Label quickly stands out from the rest; it’s not immediately better here, but the profile is the most citrus-forward of the bunch. Early flavors coalesce into lemon bars and lemon tarts, with a deft combo of sour-meets-sweet that beckons additional sips. Walnut extract provides a nutty dimension while citrus transitions to herbal, in this case thyme and lemongrass. There’s a nice burst of unfiltered apple juice right before the finish, which is light — I wouldn’t have minded even more oak and astringency here — and moderately smoked.
Summary: The King keeps its crown. While my heart lies with Green Label, my palate gives the nod to Blue. A blended Scotch synonymous with luxury — or at least the “premium” tier — Blue Label earns its reputation. It boasts high points from across the Johnnie Walker flavor spectrum, then either elevates or combines those with a unique array of fresh components.
*Image retrieved from Johnnie Walker
